Free Newsletter Signup

IdeaTango's RSS Feed

Plastic Prototype Solutions for Inventors
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Written by Brian Gates   
Ok, so you have a CAD model and are ready for prototyping, but which method or approach should you use to produce your invention? There are a lot of options out there and some companies will sell you on the highest priced solution regardless if it will fit your needs. This article while help you to determine which method you should pursue based on your production and accuracy needs.

Rapid Prototyping - One-of-a-Kinds

FDM Part

Rapid prototyping describes the method of producing a part by building up layer upon layer of material to create a finished prototype. The produced parts typically look like a deck of cards and will require some finish work to sand and smooth the surfaces. The parts can then be painted to resemble a production-ready part. While this method works great for 1-5 units, if you require larger quantities you should consider using a different method to lower costs and increase consistency. All of the following solutions are rapid prototypes: 3 dimension printing, fused deposition modeling (FDM), laminated object manufacturing, selective laser sintering and Stereo lithography (SLA).

Rapid Tooling – Few-of-a-Kinds

Rapid tooling uses a rapid prototyped part to develop a simple mold to be used for small-scale prototyping runs. The mold provides the ability to use plastic injection to create the part and some mold materials will produce up to a 100 units without failure. The only catch here is that you will have to pay extra for the mold development and this will increase the time to develop the products.

Rapid Injection Mold

Rapid Injection Molding – Some-of-a-Kinds

This approach uses your CAD model to mill out a metal mold that can be used for injection molding of your product. The choice of materials for the part is significantly broader than rapid tooling and will allow for small-scale production runs of up to 5,000 units. This can be a cheap and quick alternative to developing a traditional injection mold and a better solution than rapid tooling due to greater longevity and quality of the product. The costs for mold development can be in the thousands but unit production costs will be cheaper.


 Rapid Prototyping (RP) Rapid tooling (RT) Rapid injection molding (RIM)
Form and fit GoodGood to excellentGood to excellent
Function Poor to goodFair to goodExcellent
Non-recurring costs $0$100-1000s$1000s
Recurring costs $10s$1s to $10s$0.10s to $1s
Ideal quantities 1-1010-10025-5,000
Lead time 1-5 days5-10 days3-15 days
Other considerations Good for complex shapes; limited material choiceLimited material choiceCan be used for bridge tooling or production

Table from IDES "Plastic Prototyping: How Methods Measure Up" by Brad Cleveland.





Digg!Google!Facebook!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Spurl!Wists!Simpy!Newsvine!Blinklist!Furl!Fark!Blogmarks!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Squidoo!BlogMemes!FeedMeLinks!Tailrank!
 

Looking for more great sites for inventors?

Advertisement